The 5 Most Common Mistakes Owners Make When Training Their Dog (and How to Fix Them)

If you’ve ever watched your dog tilt their head at you like you’ve just tried to explain rocket science to them, here’s some comforting news:

It’s not them. It’s probably you.

Dog training isn’t magic, and it’s definitely not instinct. It’s a communication system — one that humans tend to butcher with enthusiasm, repetition, and a sprinkle of unintentional sabotage.

So let’s break down the five biggest mistakes owners make, why they happen, and how to fix them so you can understand your dog on a deeper level and more importantly, so that they can understand you.

‍

❌ Mistake 1: Using Words Before Behaviours Exist

Humans love talking. Dogs… not so much.

Most owners start training like this:

“Sit… sit… come on, SIT… good boy? No? Sit?”

Meanwhile your dog is just blinking, absorbing absolutely none of it.

The Problem:

Words mean nothing until the action means something.
Dogs learn in reverse order: behavior > cue > reward.

The Fix:

Teach the action first using a hand signal or lure.
Add the word once the dog is already doing it.
Reward. Repeat.
Stop narrating every second of your dog’s life.

‍

❌ Mistake 2: Accidentally Rewarding the Wrong Behaviour

Dogs aren’t moral creatures. They’re opportunists with fur.

They don’t think, “Jumping on Grandma is rude.”
They think, “I jumped on Grandma and got attention… jackpot.”

The Problem:

Your reaction becomes the reward.
Even negative attention is attention.

Classic examples:

• You push your dog off → they got touched (reward)
  
  
• You shout “No!” → they got engagement (reward)
  
  
• You let them pull → they got to move forward (reward)
  
  

The Fix:

If you don’t want a behaviour repeated, don’t pay it.
Reward calm, quiet, polite behaviour with the same enthusiasm you give chaos.

‍

❌ Mistake 3: Expecting Your Dog to “Generalise” (They Won’t)

“Why does he sit perfectly at home but forgets everything at the park?”

Because to your dog, the park is a completely different planet — sights, smells, noises, squirrels, grass, the ghost of a discarded sandwich… it’s a sensory warzone.

The Problem:

Dogs don’t connect behaviour across locations.

A trained “sit” indoors is basically meaningless outdoors.

The Fix:

Re-teach behaviours in multiple environments:

• Kitchen
  
  
• Garden
  
  
• Driveway
  
  
• Quiet street
  
  
• Busy street
  
  
• Park
  
  

Each new setting is a new level of the game.

Don’t skip levels and blame the player.

‍

❌ Mistake 4: Using Punishment Instead of Understanding

Punishment feels fast.
Understanding feels slow.

But only one actually works long-term.

The Problem:

Punishment shuts down behaviour but never solves the cause.
It can create anxiety, fear, and confusion — all of which fuel more problematic behaviours.

Instead of “stop that,” think:

“What do I want instead?”

Replace:

• Jumping → ask for “sit”
  
  
• Barking → reinforce “quiet”
  
  
• Pulling → reward loose leash moments
  
  
• Chewing furniture → provide legitimate chewing outlets
  
  

Teaching an alternative is infinitely more effective than yelling into the void.

‍

❌ Mistake 5: Forgetting That Dogs Need Routines (and Brain Work)

You know what makes dogs behave like caffeinated toddlers?

Boredom.

Bored dogs misbehave. Under-stimulated dogs act out.
Dogs without structure go rogue.

And yet, most owners accidentally under-deliver on what their dog needs mentally and emotionally.

The Problem:

People over-exercise dogs physically and under-exercise them mentally.

This leads to:

• Barking
  
  
• Whining
  
  
• Hyperactivity
  
  
• Evening chaos
  
  
• Poor focus during training
  
  
• Pulling on the leash
  
  
• “He’s just so energetic” (translation: he’s under-stimulated)
  
  

The Fix:

Add “brain work” to the daily routine:

• Sniff-led walks
  
  
• Food puzzles
  
  
• Scent games
  
  
• Lick mats
  
  
• Short obedience drills
  
  
• Foraging activities
  
  

A mentally tired dog makes better decisions.
A mentally stimulated dog makes fewer bad ones.

‍

📜 Final Verdict: Most Training Problems Are Human Problems

The good news?
Human problems are fixable.

When you stop over-talking, stop rewarding chaos, stop expecting miracles, stop punishing confusion, and start prioritising mental stimulation…

You don’t just get a “better behaved” dog.

You get a dog who:

• Trusts you
  
  
• Understands you
  
  
• Can focus around distractions
  
  
• Feels calmer
  
  
• Feels safer
  
  
• Actually enjoys learning with you
  
  

That’s the real win.